They Laughed at the Walnut. Monsanto’s Scientists Had Already Found the Signal.

Wikipedia’s article about me says I “became popular promoting alternative medicine beliefs, including ancient healing practices and the claim that the appearance of some foods indicates which organs they benefit” (Wikipedia).
That sentence rests on a single source: a 2019 McGill Office for Science and Society column by Jonathan Jarry. Jarry watched a lecture I gave in 2015 and summarized my thesis this way: “food is information that we put in our body and it interacts with our genes.” He added that I believe “a walnut looks like the brain because it’s meant to help our brain function” (McGill OSS).

Walnut kernels cut in cross-section. Photo: Ehealy93, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons.
The walnut was meant as the punchline. It is easy to mock and easy to dismiss, and the deeper claim beside it, that food carries information our genes respond to, went down with the joke.
That deeper claim is the one that matters. It turns out that ten years before Jarry’s column, scientists at the world’s largest seed company had found strong evidence for it. Their job was to explain why it didn’t matter.
The Information in Our Food
In 2009, a team of Monsanto scientists published a study of the small RNA molecules found in ordinary soybeans, corn and rice. These are the short genetic sequences plants use to switch their own genes on and off. The Monsanto team found them in abundance, including many with “perfect complementarity to human genes.” In other words, the food supply is full of plant genetic sequences that exactly match parts of our own genetic code (Ivashuta et al., Food and Chemical Toxicology 2009).

Verbatim excerpt from the 2009 Monsanto paper’s abstract. Highlights added.
Their conclusion: this “establishes a history of safe consumption for dietary small RNAs.”
Think about that logic. They found the very molecules that could, in principle, silence human genes sitting in our staple foods. They didn’t test whether those molecules get into us. They declared them safe because we have always eaten them.
That argument works only if food RNA does nothing once it is eaten. And Monsanto had a commercial reason to need that to be true. It was developing crops engineered to produce their own gene-silencing RNA: corn that makes a double-stranded RNA designed to kill the western corn rootworm by shutting down one of its genes (EPA decision document). If eaten RNA is inert, these crops are as safe as any other food. If it isn’t, every new engineered RNA sequence needs to be tested for what it might do inside us.

Western corn rootworm, the pest Monsanto’s RNA-interference corn was engineered to kill. Photo: public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Then a Chinese Lab Found It in Our Blood
In 2011–2012, Chen-Yu Zhang’s group at Nanjing University reported that plant microRNAs, especially one from rice called MIR168a, appeared in human and animal blood. In mice, it appeared to lower a liver protein involved in clearing cholesterol (Zhang et al., Cell Research 2012).

Screenshot of the 2012 Cell Research abstract on PubMed Central, highlights added. The page also shows the paper’s published correction notice.
If that held up, food really is information, quite literally. The ancient intuition that what we eat speaks to our bodies would have a molecular mechanism.
The response came fast.

How “food RNA is inert” became policy, 2009–2020.
The timeline
2012: An all-Monsanto team published an analysis calling plant microRNAs found in animal data likely “artifactual.” Its disclosure reads: “All authors were employed by Monsanto… The authors declare competing financial interests” (BMC Genomics 2012).
October 4, 2013: Monsanto petitioned the USDA to deregulate MON 87411, its first RNA-interference corn (USDA APHIS).
November 2013: A Monsanto–miRagen team published the best-known “failed replication,” reporting a “lack of detectable oral bioavailability” of plant microRNAs in rice-fed mice. Its competing-interests statement: “The authors of this publication are employed by companies that carry out research and development of products leveraging small RNAs” (Nature Biotechnology 2013). The journal’s editorial tied the paper directly to the debate over RNA-based crops (Nature Biotechnology editorial).
2017: The EPA registered the corn, the first crop of its kind (EPA).
Within a few years the verdict was set: dietary microRNAs don’t get in, and the idea was “debunked.”
To be fair, some independent academic labs also raised real concerns, mainly lab contamination and very weak signals (Kang et al., RNA 2017). Those critiques deserve to be answered on their merits, and serious researchers have been doing so. But it is worth noticing which conclusion an industry with billions at stake needed, and who did the most to supply it.
The Regulator Borrowed the Argument
When the EPA approved Monsanto’s RNA-interference corn in 2017, its human-health reasoning repeated the 2009 logic almost word for word. EPA noted that Monsanto had found 150 corn grain small RNAs with 100% sequence identity to 500 likely protein-coding human transcripts. It treated that as “further support for the history of safe consumption” and concluded that such matches “do not constitute a safety concern” (EPA decision document).

Verbatim excerpts from EPA’s 2017 MON 87411 decision document. Highlights added.
Why not a concern? Because, EPA said, “multiple and redundant biological barriers” keep eaten RNA out, and stomach acids and enzymes “are likely to ensure that all forms of RNA structure are degraded.”
That is a precautionary principle turned upside down. A perfect match between a food molecule and a human gene is exactly what a gene-silencing molecule needs. Finding hundreds of them should open an inquiry. Instead, it was treated as proof of safety.
The Barrier Turned Out to Be a Door
In 2020, a study in Cell Research identified a specific protein in the stomach lining, SIDT1, that takes up dietary microRNAs. Mice lacking it absorbed dramatically less plant RNA, and the stomach acid EPA had named as a barrier did the opposite: uptake was “SIDT1 and low-pH dependent” (Chen et al., Cell Research).

Screenshot of the SIDT1 abstract on PubMed Central (published online 2020), highlights added.
What else has emerged since the “debunking”
Independent replication. A Baylor lab found a honeysuckle small RNA (MIR2911) 10–13 times higher in the blood of mice fed vegetable diets, and far more resistant to digestion than ordinary RNAs (Scientific Reports 2016).
In humans. The same molecule went from undetectable to measurable in human blood two hours after people drank honeysuckle tea (Cell Discovery 2020).
Through the gut. Ginger’s tiny RNA-carrying particles change the behaviour of gut bacteria and protected mice from colitis. In a blinded study of 58 people, they shifted the gut microbiome (Cell Host & Microbe 2018).
None of this proves that every food microRNA reaches every tissue. The science is still contested, and I won’t pretend otherwise. But the confident claim that “food RNA can’t get in” is no longer defensible. The premise that food is information is not a superstition. It is an open, active and increasingly supported line of research, and it was ridiculed before the evidence was in.
The Body Reads Before It Swallows
“Food is information” isn’t only about molecules crossing into the blood. The body starts reading food before it is swallowed, and the measurable effects are documented.
Cyclists who only rinsed their mouths with a carbohydrate drink and spat it out finished a time trial faster than with a sweetened placebo, and brain scans showed reward and motor regions responding to the carbohydrate itself (Chambers, Bridge & Jones, Journal of Physiology 2009). A meta-analysis of 90 controlled trials confirmed small gains, including in maximum muscle force (systematic review and meta-analysis).
Plants signal, and animals evolved to read them. In 45 rainforest fruit species, about 60% of the colour variation outside red and black fruits tracked protein, tannin and carbohydrate content (Schaefer et al., Biology Letters 2004). Wild chimpanzees with parasites chew a bitter plant pith, and researchers concluded its bitterness may act “as signals to the ingester guiding their choice of the appropriate plant, plant part, and possibly also as signals which help to control the amount of intake” (Koshimizu, Ohigashi & Huffman 1994).
When that reading fails, the consequences can be deadly. Older adults who had lost their sense of smell had more than three times the odds of dying within five years (Pinto et al., PLoS One 2014).
And the Walnut?
The doctrine of signatures, the old idea that a plant’s form, colour, taste or smell points to its use, is the background to the walnut joke. Wikipedia calls it “pseudoscience” (Wikipedia).
The doctrine’s best-known academic critic doesn’t go that far. In his history of the doctrine, the ethnobotanist Bradley Bennett argues that signatures were mostly memory aids rather than how cures were discovered. But he also writes that “recent research supports the therapeutic value of many signature-bearing species,” and that walnuts, “with their often-ridiculed cotyledon signature of a human brain, may be effective in treating cerebral ailments” (Bennett, HerbalGram 2008).

Verbatim excerpt from Bennett’s 2008 HerbalGram history of the doctrine. Highlights added.
The research since then goes further.

Three peer-reviewed findings on taste, tradition and colour.
What the peer-reviewed literature shows
Taste predicts medicine. In 700 botanical drugs from the ancient Greek pharmacopoeia of Dioscorides, 21 of 22 taste qualities predicted at least one recorded therapeutic use (Leonti et al., eLife 2024).
Independent discovery. Healers in Nepal, New Zealand and South Africa, with no shared history, chose related plant groups for the same illnesses, and those groups are enriched for known bioactive plants (Saslis-Lagoudakis et al., PNAS 2012).
Present-day signatures tested. In a field study of 33 Galilee villages, 22% of signature-based plant uses already had supporting laboratory evidence. The researchers concluded that the doctrine “has exerted a major influence in identifying the plants we have come to regard as medicinal” (Dafni et al., Plants 2021).
The honest limits. The clinical evidence for walnuts and the brain is still mixed: the largest trial missed its main outcome (Sala-Vila et al., AJCN 2020). And some signature plants are toxic: birthwort, once given in childbirth, contains kidney-damaging aristolochic acids (Scientific Reports 2022).

Screenshot of the eLife abstract on PubMed Central, highlight added.
A signature points to a plant that acts on the body. It does not guarantee the effect is safe or good. That is the honest position, and it is a long way from “bunk.”
Why Some People Need This to Be a Joke
Here is what I think connects the walnut to the corn.
If food is information, if the molecules in what we eat can talk to our genes and our gut bacteria, then putting new, engineered genetic information into staple crops is not a trivial act. Every new sequence would need to be tested for what it does inside the people who eat it, not just in the pest it targets. The approval model for RNA-based crops depends on the opposite assumption: that food information stays outside us.
So the idea at the heart of my work is not merely unfashionable. It is commercially inconvenient for one of the most powerful industries on earth.
And the institution that wrote the column Wikipedia now relies on has a history with that industry. From at least October 2003 to February 2007, archived versions of the McGill Office for Science and Society homepage stated: “OSS receives support from McGill University, The Lorne Trottier Family Foundation, The Council for Biotechnology Information and private donors” (Wayback Machine, 2003; 2007). The Council for Biotechnology Information was the crop-biotech industry’s communications arm, backed by Monsanto, BASF, Dow, Bayer, DuPont and Syngenta (Friends of the Earth). Today the office says it “does not accept funding from any vested interest” (McGill OSS).

Verbatim excerpt from the archived McGill OSS homepage footer. Highlight added.
What I am and am not saying
I am not claiming that a biotech check paid for a column written twelve years after that funding line disappeared. I have no evidence of that, and I won’t assert it.
What I am saying is documented. The leading “debunkings” of dietary RNA were written by people employed by companies with products riding on the answer. A regulator adopted their “inert food” logic to approve a new class of crops. And the office whose column now defines me in the world’s most-read encyclopedia once counted the industry’s own PR council among its supporters. Readers deserve to know that before they decide whose “science” is neutral.
The Walnut Was Never the Point
Ridicule is efficient. It spares you from having to engage with an argument. Make the walnut the story, and nobody asks why Monsanto’s own scientists were cataloguing food RNAs that match human genes, or why a regulator counted those matches as reassurance.
My premise was never that every food looks like the organ it heals. It was that food is information: that the living world carries meaning our bodies are built to read, and that traditional systems of knowledge, the doctrine of signatures among them, were early, imperfect attempts to read it. The modern evidence on taste, on independent discovery across cultures, and on dietary RNA reaching the body supports that premise more every year.
The precautionary question follows from that. If food talks to our genes, who checked what the new engineered messages are saying?
Laughing at a walnut is how they avoid that question.
“I question our usual dismissal of this older approach as absurd, mystical, or even prescientific.”
Stephen Jay Gould, quoted in Bennett, HerbalGram 2008




















Comments